Postmortem Report for Precinct 19-24 for the 11/3/26 Election

Last Updated:   11/9/26  05:57                 Jeffrey Knauth
(click to jump to a section)
(click to jump to a section)

Contents


Summary

This was the third election at the Hope Lutheran Church polling place. Because of Church requirements, the Voting Enclosure was switched back to the Narthex, which we had used for the 11/4/25 election. The Narthex is somewhat cramped, compared to Friendship Hall + Lobby that we had used in March, but we made it work. The Church supplied all the furniture we needed and we were able to use the Church traffic circle for curbside, which was just what we needed. The weather was excellent for both Monday and Tuesday.

There were some significant BOE procedural problems, detailed below. Other than those, the election went very well. There was a steady, but moderate voter turnout, which was ideal for us. The curbside number was about average. Curbside worked well once the assigned Officials, all new to that area, learned the ropes.

I had been in the hospital for five days shortly before the election, had a surgery, and was not too mobile. The BOE Staff did Weekend and Monday pickup for me so I did not have to cart the Tabulator and numerous heavy boxes. Then all my Precinct Officials watched out for me on Monday and Tuesday. Thanks to all! That should put me in better shape for my followup surgery in the coming weeks.

Statistics

As of 11/3/26 the total number of registered 19-24 voters eligible to vote in this election was 5139. The turnout for this election was about 18.6% at the polling place and 44.7% via absentee voting (mail-in [???] or one-stop) for a total of about 63.2% of the Precinct 19-24 people eligible to vote in this election. In contrast, for Wake County as a whole, 60.5% of the eligible voters cast ballots.

Tabulator vs ATV counts:  954 vs 954
Provisional ballots:          6
Spoiled ballots:             14
Emergency bin ballots:        0
Challenged ballots:           0

Unreported Move Log:         15  (best guess; I remember about 1.5 pages filled)
Curbside voters:             21
ExpressVote voters:           0
Observers:                    2  (2 Precinct-Specific Observers)
                                 (0 At-Large Observers)

Eligible voters:           5139  (eligible to vote in this election)

Monday-list absentees:     2289  (the long list in pollbook box #1)
Last-minute absentees:        7  (the short list gotten from the PO website)
                           ----
Total absentees:           2296

Voting booths set up:        17  (includes 1 provisional and 1 accessible)
Total chairs at tables:      10      (one broken booth of the 18 provided)
                             --
Total "booths"               27

Here is the Ballot Count Reconciliation web page.

Staffing, Emails, and Votari

  1. We were assigned thirteen Officials for this election. We had two dropouts, but they were replaced quickly.
  2. Spam filtering caused difficulties when contacting four of the Officials.
  3. Votari seemed to have a number of problems and was replaced.
  4. I put key files on my website as reference material for the Officials in Precinct 19-24.
  5. Officials rotated thru the various positions a great deal during Election Day.

Polling Place Setup

  1. See our Voting Enclosure layout and voter path diagrams. We configured for three Registration Table (RT) lines. That means the RT lines can be only 4-feet wide because that part of the Narthex is narrow. I prefer using 6-feet-wide lines, but that is not possible in the Narthex. The 4-feet lines do allow wheelchairs and baby-carriages.
  2. We did not need to set up a rain table for this election.
  3. For curbside layout information, see curbside.
  4. Diagrams show our outside signs and inside signs layouts. Some of our unique signs and other items are shown in special material.
  5. The Hope Lutheran Church preschool was still in session on Election Day. That complicates voter parking.
  6. An attempt was made via a Nextdoor social media post to warn voters about special considerations for the Hope Lutheran polling place. The post linked to the 19-24.htm web page, which also has a lot of "how to" election information, e.g., how to see/change your voter registration information and access your sample ballot.

ATV Form, Photo ID, and HAVA ID

  1. I audited all 954 ATVs and found only two problems, which were at the Ballot Table. One was a misnumbering and the other was that the ballot style had not been entered -- both easily fixed. Our HT Officials found a case in which the RT Official had not marked a "Send To Help Table" box on the ATV.
  2. We did not have any significant photo ID problems. A far as I know, all voters successfully used an NC driver license for the ID. We had no HAVA ID exceptions. There were MANY "V" pollbook labels, some of which we had to handle in this election.
  3. One voter forgot to bring in their photo ID. The voter had ignored all the reminder signs along the way from their car and the replacement Door Monitor had incorrectly not reminded them when they entered the Voting Enclosure. That voter was sent from the Registration Table to the Help Table, per my RT card, and then went to successfully retrieve their ID, returning to the Help Table to complete all processing there, per the Photo ID Quick Guide.
  4. One voter did not have a photo ID and remarkably said she did not know she needed one. She said she did not listen to the news. She also said she had voted before recently and had not been asked for a photo ID. (That certainly sounded suspicious.) I told her she could vote provisionally and fill out the appropriate forms. She said she had now decided not to vote. We marked No ID and Photo ID on the ATV, then voided the ATV and put it in the Spoiled bag. I did call the Help Line to let them know about this peculiar case. I gave the lady my card with my website address, in particular for the 19-24.htm link which has pointers to all the WakeBOE and NCSBE pages on photo ID requirements.

Registration Table

  1. On Tuesday I gave each Official a copy of my index-card-size "flowchart", which describes the RT procedures. I had forgotten to do that at Monday Setup. The card points out things that are sometimes missed by RT Officials. The RT card is easier to follow than the RTQG flowchart. It also corrects some problems in the RTQG flowchart. On Election Day the RT Officials used that card for their personal notes and had the RT Quick Guide flowchart taped to the table, as required by the BOE. During the day I often had the Officials refer to the card to answer a question they had.
  2. The most serious problem we had was that one of the RT Officials attached the wrong label to the ATV and the voter did not catch it. Two mistakes! Later the true owner of the label (now missing) came in to vote and had to vote provisionally. It was not her fault in any way and she was understandably upset.

    Our HT Official did some good detective work, using the pretty illegible signature on the "missing" label's ATV eventually found by the BT Officials. Apparently the RT Official and voter had properly worked together to originally find and verify the correct label. But then the RT Official removed the label just above the correct one and attached that to the ATV. Then when the voter was told to verify the label and certification words, she ignored that the wrong label had been attached (that label's name and address were nowhere close to her name and address). She then incorrectly signed the ATV; the RT Official initialed it; and the voter proceeded to vote with the wrong label. Fortunately there was only one ballot style involved in this election, so after the correct voter voted provisionally, all should work out in the counts. However, the bad voter would not show up as having voted, since she had voted with someone else's label.

    The details of all this were spelled out on the provisional envelope.

    Of course I then reemphasized to the RT Officials that they damn better attach the right label every time. Follow the card!  Don't depend on the voter to catch that the wrong label might have been attached vs the one the voter and RT Official had previously agreed on verbally.

  3. Only a couple of people signed the Voter Assistance Log at the RT.
  4. I think we had only one "F" exception. The completed form was returned in the Blue Bag.
  5. I will continue to try to get the BOE Staff to replace the current RTQG flowchart with my merged flowchart.

Ballot Table

  1. We had only one ballot style, but still used two BT Officials and a scanner. Our original scanner was defective. The Staff replaced it Monday night.
  2. Several times our ATV-Tabulator match count was off by 1, causing a lot of consternation. But our lead BT Official always beat it to the ground and we ended the day with an exact match.

Help Table

  1. There were many "V"s in the pollbooks and we had a lot of HT work to deal with -- transfers, unreported moves, etc.
  2. The unreported move process broke down badly. Supposedly there was now a search facility to quickly find another precinct's phone numbers. How to do the search was not documented. The Help Line people said there was some magnifying glass icon. There was not. So the HT Officials had to scroll and scroll and scroll to get to a 19 precinct, for example. I eventually found another way to do the search (no magnifying glass icon) and told the Help Line how to do it. They never gave me any feedback.

    However even when the phone numbers could be found, almost always there would be no answer or some sort of answering machine non-answer to all the numbers tried. The Help Line people's solution was: "Just keep trying." This wasted a huge amount of time; meanwhile the person being "helped" just had to sit there for 20+ minutes.

    I, the Chief Judge, ending up often handling the duties (pink "'T", move log, etc.) of a "called" HT Official since the other precincts called me (top name on the list) and my HT Officials were tied up trying to call other precincts, or do other HT work for people waiting to be served. Fortunately we had two Officials and two laptops.

    Further details on all this were sent to Elections via emails right after the election.

    It appeared some POs in other polling places did not understand how to handle unreported moves. A voter ended up being told she had to come to our polling place (her old precinct) even though she could have been handled as an unreported move in her new precinct. We understand she finally just decided not to vote, even provisionally. Our HT Officials say there may have been as many as three voters that other precincts should have been handled as unreported moves from our precinct, but did not.

    One of our HT Officials suggested that the BOE Staff should distribute a printed list of HT Officials' phone numbers. I suspect there might be privacy concerns about doing that. (However, I would not have a problem with the Staff publicizing my number.) I think the Staff just needs to fix and properly document the search facility.

    But most importantly, find out why the phones are not being answered. Do all HT Officials have their phones appropriately programmed, e.g., to accept a call from an unknown number? All four of our HT-trained officials received and answered many "unreported move" and other calls during the day, so all our phones were properly set up to participate. The Staff needs to research and document all such impediments if the HT personnel phones will continue to be the direction. When I was getting the HT calls, the caller ID sometimes listed some strange, out-of-state, location. That can happen. For example when one of my POs calls me, her cell phone is still tied to Philadelphia, PA, so that is what shows up since that is where her cell phone number was registered.Perhaps something like that might cause a call not to be answered, but instead switched to voicemail or just not answered at all.

Line Monitor and Door Monitor

  1. In this election we had enough Officials to designate one as the combined Door Monitor and Line Monitor. That Official asked (or was supposed to ask) every entering voter if they had brought in their photo ID before the voter got in an RT line.
  2. We never had a large enough surge of voters that caused any to be asked to wait outside the Voting Enclosure door.

Curbside

  1. We had 21 curbside voters this election. I think one time we had three cars in the line. None of our Officials had previous curbside experience, so there was a break-in period. However soon it all ran very smoothly. We often had two Officials working simultaneously. The Church loop we used this time was excellent for curbside work.
  2. We had several people in curbside cars fill in the Voter Assistance Log. I don't think there were any "F" curbside voters.
  3. All these new processes and the old photo ID check mean the Curbside Official now has to carry many pieces of paper out to the car; it's no longer just an ATV that is required or may be needed at the car. To handle this problem, I put together a special folder for each Curbside Official to hold all this material. I taped my curbside diagram to the front together with a pen that the Curbside Official could use instead of the pen tied to the privacy sleeve that the voter uses. See below for comments on the Survey QR sheet.
  4. Given that we were able to use the Church loop for curbside, we did not need to use the LED lighting system provided by the BOE. The Church has some good lighting by the door in that area vs the curbside area we had to use a year ago.

Coordinator

  1. We had one visit from our Coordinator. She found no problems with our setup and was happy with everything we were doing.

Voters

No voters acted improperly. All seemed to be in a pretty good mood.

Campaigners/Others

  1. There were few Campaigners. There were no big problems with any of them.
  2. As usual, the Church did not want any Campaigners to use Church restrooms (school children considerations). I put a sign to that effect on the Red Door (the Voting Enclosure door); I thought the Church had agreed to put a sign on the Lobby door, but there was none. Since the Lobby was not part of the Voter Enclosure for this election, we Election Officials have no say-so about the Lobby and its restroom access.

    I heard no campaigner gripes on the restroom restriction, but because of my illness I spent less time outside in this election than I normally do. However one of our Officials reported that a young woman campaigner had complained about not being allowed to use a Church restoom. We understand that later her sister drove her to some offsite restroom. This does not seem to be the older woman who had complained at the last election. They do not seem to understand or appreciate why schools have such restrictions. I have often tried to get the BOE Staff to tell the political parties to warn their campaigners BEFORE the election about such restrictions so we POs don't always have to be the bearers of the bad news.

  3. After poll closing and we had printed the Tabulator tapes, I hung tape #3 in a well-lit area near the door. Campaigners took pictures of the tape. I later took the tape home to provide some data for this postmortem.

Observers

We had two Observers in this election, one in the morning and one in the afternoon. I had set up a table for their use. There were no problems. They took pictures during poll opening and closing. Both were very interested in what we do. I let them look at copies of some of the things I give our Officials, things unique to our polling place, e.g., the RT card and the curbside sheet. I also gave them a card with my website address. Both completed the form to be future Precinct Officials.

ExpressVote

  1. We had no ExpressVote users.
  2. For this election, as for the ones before, I had copied the relevant pages from the Manual and Chief Judge Pocket Guide so I could put a hardcopy of those pages by the ExpressVote. There is still no hardcopy setup/use/takedown document packed with the ExpressVote as there had been with the AutoMark. That lack of easily accessible documentation where it is most needed seems to be a problem.

Tabulator and Black Tabulator Base

There were no problems in this area.

Reconciliation Process

  1. The end-of-day ballot reconciliation did not work as well as it should have. Normally our lead Ballot Table Official does the final ballot bookkeeping on a worksheet and on a draft Reconciliation form, so it is then easy for the Judges to later copy the draft numbers to the official Reconciliation Form. However in this election the BOE Staff insisted that that person had to be the Gold Envelope Runner. For some reason (never explained to me) the Runner had to be Help Table trained. But that meant my lead BT Official was the only possible Runner candidate. That meant the end-of-day BT bookkeeping had to be done by someone less familiar with the process. She made a simple mistake of not including the 100 ExpressVote ballots and it took a while to find that. The Gold Runner process needs to be fixed so more candidates are available. I had warned the Staff before the election that this was probably going to be a problem for our precinct. I had made a mistake of not ensuring the BT Officials were aware of this potential problem and had started working earlier in the day to handle the upcoming loss of the lead BT Official; I had thought they definitely knew what was coming. Live and learn. We eventually got all the forms correct.
  2. Here is the properly filled in worksheet from which the Reconciliation Form numbers could be copied, first to a draft Reconciliation Form and then to the official one: Ballot Count Reconciliation for 11/3/26.

Packing Up

  1. Packing up is always a hectic time, as we rush to meet the deadline for the dropoff site. We use a Packing Up after the Election set of pages to try to keep things organized. One of our Officials acted as a packup coordinator and did a very good job. Everything ended up in the right place.
  2. For this election the Church provided all the tables and chairs we needed. In the two previous elections at Hope Lutheran the BOE had provided the furniture; it proved to be much too little and yet was difficult to pack for return to the BOE.
  3. The BOE movers put the BOE items in the Narthex vs the closet where we had expected them to be. That worked out OK for us. Trying to stuff all those items in the closet might not have worked. Tuesday night we just put everything back where it had been delivered originally and told the Church personnel we would do that.

Supply Pickups and Delivery

  1. As noted above, the BOE Staff did the Weekend and Monday supply pickup for me since I was somewhat immobile. That worked very well.
  2. Tuesday night supply dropoff had some MAJOR problems with lighting, directions, and general organization at the dropoff site. These problems were also encountered by our Gold Envelope Runner. Detailed emails about all this were sent to Elections right after the election.

Hardware and Supplies

  1. We red-tagged a voting booth that had only three legs.
  2. Our original scanner was defective. It was replaced by the Staff Monday night. The Staff person took back the bad scanner.
  3. We were given five binders (needed six) and two of the five were bad. A Staff person brought some replacements. There were no HAVA ID sheets in them so I made some at home Monday night.
  4. That Staff person also brought replacement Red and Blue bags, saying those I had gotten via Weekend pickup were bad. She couldn't say exactly why the originals were bad. I just took the replacements.
  5. I often found the Help Line sound to be garbled and/or with a lot of background noise.
  6. There were some ballot misreads by the Tabulator although the ballots seemed perfectly marked. This happened twice from one pack and a third time from another pack.
  7. We received no Canvass Date sign.

See Hardware and Supplies for some other supplies comments from past elections that still apply, e.g., for the CJ lanyard and card holder.

See BOE Wish List for my current general wish list.

Documentation and Training

  1. It was very good to provide Chief Judges the ability to take the Help Table course online and to give them access to the Basic module.
  2. Over the months before this election I have emailed to the BOE Staff a lot of document comments. Some of the more significant are also noted in Actions for Remaining Proposals and Comments.
  3. The three "F" documents used at the Registration Table and at curbside were never put on the PO website under Training Resources.
  4. The assistance instructions on the back of the VA Log differ from those in the Manual, e.g., the unnecessary requirement that the Chief Judge must participate. I didn't..
  5. The late information about "F" did not make it to the Manual or curbside instructions, e.g., on the back of the privacy sleeve. Hopefully the NCSBE is being told (OFTEN!) that their late changes can cause worse problems than the problems they think they are solving.

Miscellaneous

  1. We put a found driver license in the Blue Bag as well as contact data for someone else who had reported a lost license.
  2. People reported other lost things (phone, insurance papers), which we couldn't find. No one gave me any details on those to put in the Blue Bag. I emailed the Church to contact the BOE if they found anything later, maybe in the parking lots.
  3. We were given a new H-Frame Survey sign to plant (minor warning about that) and some survey sheets to add to the pile of curbside material (no warning about those). For far around our Voting Enclosure exit door, there is only concrete and asphalt. The closet grass is about 20 feet away. That's where the sign was planted. I doubt anyone saw it. As for the additional curbside stuff:  ARE YOU KIDDING?!  Even more to carry to curbside and to slow down and confuse curbside processing? Is no one paying attention to this curbside problem? It's getting to the point where even my special curbside folders are overflowing. This survey stuff seems superfluous. You should be making things simpler, not more complicated.
  4. There were no Quick Guides in the CJ Binder. I usually mark up these to make the official ones to be returned to me and then to you at poll closing. Now I have to defer the marking-up until Monday night when I can get copies from the kits.

Future Considerations

  1. See Actions for Remaining Proposals and Comments.
  2. Put the PO assignees list back on the PO website. I was told it was removed because it had personal data (which data?), not because it named the POs and exposed them to harassment. The assignees list was very useful, e.g., to let a PO learn the name of the CJ for the PO's assigned precinct. Then the PO would know to expect contact from that CJ and should regularly check if that person had been spam filtered. More on this is in suggestions about CJs contacting their assigned Officials.

Photos

Photos and explanatory text for the pre-setup Hope Lutheran Church site are in the Hope Lutheran Church album.

Photos and explanatory text about the post-setup 19-24 Voting Enclosure, voting equipment, etc., are in the Election in the 11-3-2026 album.

If you are unfamiliar with viewing Google Photo albums, here are some hints. In particular, note how to use the "circle i" to view the full text beside each picture. When viewing the information, be sure to scroll to the top; sometimes Google Photos starts the information display partway down.

Report written by Jeff Knauth, Chief Judge for 19-24
with input from the other Officials for this precinct
HOME